| Mapping the 1854 London
Cholera Outbreak
Dr. John Snow is regarded as one of the
founding fathers of modern epidemiology. As London suffered a series
of
cholera outbreaks during the mid-19th century, Snow theorized that
cholera reproduced in the human body and was spread through contaminated
water. This contradicted the prevailing theory that diseasses were
spread by "miasma" in the air.
London's water supply system
consisted of shallow public wells where people could pump their own water
to carry home, and about a dozen water utilities that drew water from the
Thames to supply a jumble of water lines to more upscale houses.
London's sewage system was even more ad hoc: privies emptied into
cesspools or cellars more often than directly into sewer pipes.
So the
pervasive stench of animal and human feces combined with rotting garbage
made the miasma theory of disease seem very plausible. Disease was more
prevalent in lower-class neighborhoods because they stank more, and
because the supposed moral depravity of poor people weakened their
constitutions and made them more vulnerable to disease.
The September 1854 cholera outbreak was centered in the
Soho district, close to Snow's house. Snow mapped the 13 public wells and
all the known cholera deaths around Soho, and noted the spatial clustering
of cases around one particular water pump on Broad Street (now
called Broadwick Street). He
examined water samples from various wells under a microscope, and
confirmed the presence of an unknown bacterium in the Broad Street
samples. Despite strong scepticism from the local authorities, he
had the pump handle removed
from the Broad Street pump and the outbreak quickly subsided.
Snow subsequently published a map of the epidemic
to support his theory.
A scan of this map is shown
below. It shows the locations of the 13 public water sources
in and around Soho, and shows cholera deaths by home address, marked as
black bars stacked perpendicular to the streets.
Some anomalies are worth noting. Although the
large workhouse just north of Broad Street housed over 500 paupers, it
suffered very few cholera deaths because it had its own well (not shown on
the map). Likewise, The workers at the brewery one block east of
the Broad Street could drink all the beer they wanted; the
fermentation killed the cholera bacteria,
and none of the brewery workers contracted cholera.
Many of the deaths further away from the Broad Street pump
were people who walked to work or market on the Broad Street and
drank from that well. Other deaths were attributable to the
superior taste of the water from Broad Street, particularly
compared to the smelly water from the Carnaby Street/Little Marlborough
Street well.
Steven Johnson's 2006 book The Ghost Map: the Story of London's
Most Terrifying Epidemic, and How it Changed Science, Cities and
the Modern World (available in paperback) is a highly entertaining
account of the
epidemic and Snow's analysis of it.
Analysis of Dr. Snow's map
|