Title: Modeling and Assessing Online Discussions for Faculty Development
The problem
Although use of online discussions is frequently cited as evidence that technology is aiding the learning process, there is little data to support that claim. Furthermore, there is
little evidence beyond anecdotal that
faculty development workshops are successful. Staff from the
Description of
Activity
There are two main phases in this study. During phase one, faculty will participate in online asynchronous discussions to develop skills in facilitating collaboration and higher levels of thinking. Through the workshop content, faculty will experience problem-based teaching and learning strategies that they can apply to their courses.
At the workshop, faculty are
divided into groups to work through a problem about increasing the quality of
online postings. The problem assumes
that the faculty are team teaching an
interdisciplinary course in Current Middle Eastern Issues and want their
students to move from emotional responses to critical thinking. They meet in
person and then separate and use the online discussions to propose strategies,
find online resources, and develop questions to ask an expert in an online asynchronous
discussion. The expert in online
discussions, Barbara Frey, from the
The
In phase two, the facililtators will analyze the quality of the online discussions and the feedback from faculty both immediately following the session and later in the semester. The online discussion postings will be analyzed with content analysis maps that diagram initial (or parent) postings and the participant responses that branch from the original assignment, question, or comment. Our analysis will consider four qualities: (1) statements and the cognitive level of thinking according to Bloom’s Taxonomy, (2) questions, (3) affirmations or social comments, and (4) personal reflections. We will analyze postings in order to identify strategies and content that were effective in developing rich threads of dialogue.
After presenting the phases one and two, the presenters will invite participants to react to our data and provide suggestions regarding the structure and content of the workshop. The final step will be for participants to draw up an action plan for implementing online discussions or problem solving teaching strategies on their campus.