|
NEWS: Senate Panel Focuses on Public Diplomacy
and
Islam;
Voices Support for
Exchanges
February 27, 2003 Calling exchanges “critically important”, Senate Foreign
Relations Committee Chairman Richard Lugar (R-IN) today called for increasing
exchange efforts and boosting the number of international students who come
to the U.S.
“The missing ingredient in American public diplomacy between the
fall of the
Berlin Wall and the September 11 attacks…was a firm commitment by the American
people and the American leadership to all the painstaking work required to build
lasting relationships overseas and advance our vision of fairness and opportunity.
The experience of September 11 jarred us out of our complacency, but this Committee
is anxious to ensure that the best
public diplomacy strategy is being developed,” Lugar said at a Senate hearing
this morning.
Ranking committee Democrat, Sen. Joseph Biden (D-DE), criticized
the Bush
Administration’s budget request. “…The request for international exchange
programs which are essential to exposing thousands of people to the United
States and U.S. citizens is reduced in the President’s budget for Fiscal Year
2004….This will result in real reductions nearly 2,500 fewer participants in
exchanges next year….As our diplomatic efforts on Iraq have made plain, we cannot
take any allies old or new for granted. We must constantly engage them. We
should expand our international broadcasting and international exchanges, not
contract them. They are valuable tools to tell
America’s story to the world.”
Sen. Russell Feingold (D-WI) echoed Biden’s remarks
in his own introductory
statement for the record. “Perhaps the most important form of American power
projected over the last century has been the power of our ideas and values. If
we lose our capacity to lead in that sense, then all of us sitting here, all
of us in government, will have presided over the greatest loss of power in American
history, regardless of how much we spend on our mighty and admirable military
forces. And we will have put ourselves at a
great disadvantage likely a decisive and crippling disadvantage in the fight
against terrorism,” Feingold said.
Witnesses at the hearing included Amb. Kenton
Keith, chair of the Alliance board of directors, and Charlotte Beers, Under
Secretary of State for Public Diplomacy and Public Affairs. Alliance Calls
for $100 Million
for Islamic Exchanges and a Balanced Visa Policy.
In his testimony, Keith called
for $100 million above the current appropriation for State exchanges to fund
an Islamic exchange initiative. Keith encouraged Lugar to reintroduce the Cultural
Bridges Act, which the chairman cosponsored in the last Congress with Sen.
Edward Kennedy (D-MA)
and 12 Senate cosponsors.
“This amount of money spent on promoting our ideas
and values is very small when compared to the sums we will expend on military
hardware, but it is no
less crucial to our success,” Keith stated.
On visas, Keith reported on the
growing concern at University of Kansas, where he serves on an advisory board
for international
programs, that the best foreign students, scholars and researchers are beginning
to look elsewhere for higher education, as they regard the U.S. as inhospitable
to them. Keith stressed that without a balanced visa policy, “our nation will
be squandering one of its most valuable foreign policy assets the opportunity
to educate the next generation of world leaders.”
Beers’ statement reflected
the importance of exchanges: “Among the lessons of 9/11 is that our educational
and cultural exchanges be they of young
leaders, academics, students, or others are almost always positive, literally
transforming, experiences. ….It is impossible to calculate the return on this
investment. It would be too high to be believable. Fifty per cent of the leaders
of the global coalition in the war against terrorism had been International
Visitors. More than 200 current and former Heads of State, 1,500 cabinet-level
ministers,
and many other distinguished leaders in government and the private sector from
around the world have participated
in the International Visitor program.”
“There’s also a problem,” Beers continued. “The
number of exchanges 35,000 a year worldwide is nowhere near enough and
should be expanded in the future, since they are so productive. The transformation
of
perceptions and the recognition of commonality that we realized after 9/11
are so important must take place for millions, not just thousands. We have
to go
beyond the significant dialogue we have with government officials and country
leaders and reach out to mass audiences,” Beers said. She noted
that the Administration’s FY04 budget request is “basically straight lined.”
Beers
called English teaching programs “a secret weapon,”noting that regardless
of attitudes toward the United States, virtually every nation is eager for
its citizens
to become more proficient in English. She noted in particular that English
is a gateway to advancement in scientific and technical fields.
In response
to an
inquiry from Feingold, Beers explained State’s new “Secure
Borders/Open Doors” program, being developed to harness resources of several
government agencies to “speak with one voice” on visas. The program attempts
to give clear, comprehensive, and reliable information about the visa process,
including links to official websites and stories from students and visitors
who have gone through the process.
Copyright
2003
by Alliance for International Educational and Cultural Exchange
1776 Massachusetts
Avenue, NW Suite 620
Washington, DC 20036
Tel: (202) 293-6141
Fax: (202)
293-6144
Web: http://www.alliance-exchange.org
Email: spowar@alliance-exchange.org
Used with permission of the Alliance for International Educational and Cultural
Exchange.
This file was updated on November 8,
2003
|