March 18, 2005

 

Taken from the Policy Statements for the College of Marine Studies.  The section relevant to the proposed new Master of Marine Management is in italics and bold. 

Graduate Program

Policy Statement C/X/04

Supersedes Policy Statement C/1/85, C/1/75, C/2/77, C/1/78, S/1/75, S/2/77 and C/1/82

1. Administration

a.  Responsibility for day-to-day administration of the CMS academic program has been assigned by the Dean to the Associate Dean. Day-to-day administration of each of the four program areas is the responsibility of a program director. Oversight and coordination of the college-wide academic program reside with the CMS Academic Council.

b.  All core faculty members of the college are eligible to teach graduate and undergraduate courses and to serve as principal advisor, or as an advisory committee member, subject to the approval of the respective program director and associate dean.

 

c. Individuals other than college faculty may be permitted to teach specific graduate or undergraduate courses during specific terms if both the course and instructor are approved by the appropriate program director, the academic council, the associate dean, and the dean. 

 

2.  Admission

 

a.  The college generally admits applicants with combined verbal and quantitative GRE scores at least 1050, good advanced test scores, and an overall grade point index exceeding 3.0.  The Associate Dean may discuss questionable applications with the Academic Council, especially those with GRE scores below 1050 and GPA below 3.0.  For students applying for the Master of Marine Management (MMM) degree, professional experience is encouraged and is an important consideration for admission.       

  

Admission to the graduate program is competitive. Those who meet stated requirements are not guaranteed admission, nor are those who fail to meet all of those requirements necessarily precluded from admission if they offer other appropriate strengths.

 

b. The academic programs of CMS may establish additional criteria for evaluating prospective students.  These additional criteria shall be reviewed by Academic Council.

 

c. Each program director, after consultation with his/her faculty, makes a recommendation to the associate dean on those applications in his/her program area.

 

d.   The MMM degree program will be administered by a three member committee (MMM Advisory Committee) composed of the Program Director for Marine Policy and two faculty mentors.  One of the mentors will be from the Marine Policy program and the other from one of the other programs in CMS.  This committee will oversee admissions and guide students through the program.  The committee will report to the Associate Dean who in turn will consult with Academic Council when necessary.

 

e.  Before qualified students are admitted to the college, a specific faculty member must indicate a willingness to advise and supervise the student. The program director appoints the faculty advisor pro tem; at the initiative of faculty or student, the advisor may be changed.  Students in the MMM program are advised by the MMM Advisory Committee.  

 

3.  Policies for Matriculated Students 

 

a.  The requirements for all degrees offered by CMS are described at http://www.ocean.udel.edu/graduate/degrees.html.  All degrees except the M.M.M. degree require a thesis or dissertation describing original work completed by the student.

 

b. A student must complete his/her graduate work within the time limits imposed by the University and CMS.  The time limits for the various steps in completing the M.S. or Ph.D. are given at http://www.ocean.udel.edu/currentstudents/policy.html#13.   

 

c. On petition, waivers of the time limits may be granted for good cause.

Students must provide justification for any extensions past the limits.  The justification must be approved by the student’s advisor, committee and the Associate Dean.   In the case of University time limits, the official request to the graduate office must come from the associate dean of CMS.

 

d. A doctoral student's committee shall consist of at least four members but not more than six, at least 50% of whom shall be CMS core faculty. It is required that one member of the committee be external to the college. A magisterial student's committee shall consist of at least three members, but not more than four, at least two of whom shall be CMS core faculty. 

 

e. Core, joint, adjunct, emeritus appointees, and university research professors assigned to CMS are considered as members of the CMS faculty, but every doctoral or magisterial committee must have at least two core appointee. Only core or joint appointees may serve as committee chairs, except in the case of an emeritus professor who has, prior to retirement, been the advisor of a student when that student's committee was formed.

 

f. A qualifying examination is required to obtain admission to candidacy for the Ph.D. In order to take the examination, each student must be in good academic standing, have satisfied the requirements of the academic program (with the exception of the annual seminar requirement), have an approved research proposal, and have approval of the advisory committee. Each Ph.D. candidate is required to pass written and oral qualifying examinations in those areas of marine studies designated by the advisory committee. At least 60 days prior to the examination, the student will be advised by the committee of those areas and format of marine studies to be tested. Passage or failure of the examination is determined by advisory committee consensus. A student who fails is entitled to only one re-examination, which must be taken within six months of the first examination.

 

g. The defense of the dissertation or thesis, which is required for all degrees except the M.M.M. degree, is addressed to the candidate's research. The examination focuses on the scope of the research, its contribution to the field, its significance to advancing the body of knowledge, and its potential for follow-up. The student's advisory committee serves as the examining board.

 

The defense is oral and is open to the public and should be announced at least two weeks before the defense date.

 

The defense will begin with a presentation of the work by the candidate, followed by questioning by the examiners. Thereafter, the defense will be open to questions addressed to the candidate by the public. At the close of the public questioning, the examiners will retire immediately for deliberation and decision. Upon reaching a decision, the board will communicate that decision to the candidate, the dean of the College of Marine Studies, and the Office of Graduate Studies. Dissertations must be submitted to the Office of Graduate Studies according to the deadline schedule published by the Office of Graduate Studies.

 

4.  Change in Student Status   

a. A student may change advisor in consultation with the assigned advisor and the potential advisor. Additional advisement is provided by the program director and the student's advisory committee.

b. Students who have formed an advisory committee and who have completed an M.S. thesis proposal may petition for admission to the Ph.D. program after one year of residency in the college (“bypass option”).

To petition, students must submit evidence of performance to their M.S. advisory committee. Such evidence generally includes:

    • Excellent grades in graduate courses
    • Promising research results
    • Sound plans for Ph.D.-level research

The following steps are necessary for approving the bypass:

Chair of advisory committee sends a letter of approval on behalf of the majority of the advisory committee to the program director. The letter should note dissent, if any;

Associate dean reviews the letter and input from program director;

Student completes a change-of-status form and continues as a Ph.D. student in the College.

e.  Students wishing to transfer into the MMM program from another CMS degree program must petition the MMM Advisory Committee.  Students wishing to transfer to another CMS degree from the MMM program must reapply for admission to CMS.  There is no fee for this application.  The application procedure is the same as for other students. 

 

d.  Students who wish to continue for a Ph.D. after completing an M.S. must reapply for admission to CMS. There is no fee for this application. The application procedure is the same as for other students.  Typically, the letters of recommendation will be from the prospective Ph.D. advisor and two members of the M.S. advisory committee. 

5.  Competency of CMS graduates

A recipient of a Ph.D. from the University of Delaware generally must have the analytical skills and intellectual scholarship to perform research with independent creativity. This criterion is demonstrated by the submission of a written dissertation of original research expressing profound knowledge and new discoveries in one area of marine studies; this accomplishment should gain wide recognition through a publication of one or more articles in an internationally recognized and refereed journal or equivalent medium. A second criterion is unique to the CMS graduate program — a broad understanding of both scientific and socio-political issues related to the oceans.

For the M.S. and M.M.P. degrees, the above criteria are the same except for the depth of understanding, creativity, and independence demonstrated in one area of marine studies by the dissertation. Instead, a written thesis is required. It must, by definition, be of a stated hypothesis with originality that may warrant publication, or a profound analysis of some policy issue with critical conclusions. Here the intent is a focused and limited exposure to research; the duration is not meant to exceed a year. In this respect, the doctoral and master's degrees granted in the College of Marine Studies aim toward a common breadth of understanding and differ only in intensity and scholarship of the written research.

Students receiving the M.M.M. degree are not required to write a thesis or to conduct original research or analysis.  These students should have a solid foundation in the aspects of marine science and policy relevant to their areas of marine management.    

6.  Changes in Requirements

Any program wishing to change requirements for their graduate students, including imposing additional requirements, must seek approval of Academic Council.  The Council will then determine if the change should be considered by the entire CMS faculty.

Legislative History

  • Draft given by Associate Dean Carolyn A. Thoroughgood to Program Directors for review and comment - December 1981.
  • Draft C/1/82 circulated to Faculty - 10 February 1982.
  • Faculty recommended adoption of draft C/1/82.
  • Dean W.S. Gaither adopted and promulgated C/1/82 - 3 March 1982.
  • COMSEX reviewed and recommended retention after modification - 25 February 1985.
  • Dean Thoroughgood promulgated - 1 December 1985.
  • Revised by Academic Council annually and sent to Office of Graduate Studies for approval.
  • A decision was made that the revised Graduate Program Policy Statement would be placed in the CMS Student Advisement Manual with a note to that affect in this policy manual - 1 May 1992.
  • Some sections of the CMS Student Advisement Manual (now Current Student information) were moved back to this section.  Revised and approved by Academic Council-27 July 2004
  • Approved by Faculty-
  • Promulgated by Interim Dean Nancy Targett-